S ingle-stream recycling collection and processing in North America is widely considered to have gained its initial momentum on the
Pacific Coast. In the eastern half of the U.S., single-stream methods
are just beginning to take root, although equipment makers and
recycling program managers note that switches in several programs have taken place in the past two years.
Among the programs adopting the method are several smaller communities in New York State and New England, who are offering a look at whether single stream makes economic sense in areas beyond the major population centers.
SWEEPING CHANGE IN BROOME COUNTY
Broome County, N.Y., is a three-hour drive west of Manhattan, and the rural and small town nature of the region is markedly different from the Big Apple. County seat Binghamton has a population of nearly 50,000, while the county’s other 150,000 people live in smaller towns, villages and sparsely populated townships.
The State of New York has long had a bottle bill pertaining to beverage containers, but programs throughout the state collect old newspapers (ONP) and other paper grades as well as steel cans and non-refundable plastic and glass containers.
Many of the Broome County cities and villages, including Binghamton, had been operating a dual-stream recycling program since the early 1990s. But when Kevin Roche, deputy commissioner of public works and solid waste, and other county officials evaluated the recycling program, they identified some areas that could be changed.
"We had a desire to reduce overall recycling costs for hauling and for processing," says Roche. "We also wanted to increase diversion and reach a new audience in recycling. Single-stream is a way to make it easier for people to participate."
The county made a major commitment to single-stream up front in its bidding process, when it guaranteed a 10-year contract to the winning proposal. "We had to guarantee some level of quantity, and we also guaranteed a 10-year contract; that got the interest of the private sector to make the investment," says Roche.
Waste Management Inc., Houston, was the winning bidder to operate the county’s material recovery facility (MRF). The company and the county retrofitted an old manufacturing facility in central Binghamton that now serves as one of the smaller single-stream MRFs in operation in the U.S. "I call it a micro-MRF," says Roche.
The 20,000 sq. ft. tipping, processing and finished storage area contains a Bollegraaf/Lubo fiber and container sorting screen, an Andela glass breaker, live-bottom floor bunkers to keep fiber moving and a Harris HRB baler. A John Deere wheel loader keeps material moving from the tipping area to the sort line, while a Toyota forklift transports finished bales. The sorting system can handle up to 10 tons per hour throughout an eight-hour shift.
Waste Management charges the county a pre-determined service fee, with a percentage of commodity revenues subtracted. "It’s a formulated revenue share based on a blended value of all commodities," says Roche. "The contractor gets the first $40 per ton, while of the balance, 65 percent goes to the county and 35 percent goes to the contractor."
According to Roche, the single-stream system, which started up in the fall of 2002, has been a winner all the way around:
• "Residents are participating more be-
cause they do not have the previously
confusing container requirements,"
says Roche. "With haulers using single
compartment trucks to collect
recyclables now, residents are also
seeing fewer trucks making trips back and forth to the tipping floor."
• Haulers, says Roche, also benefit by
using the single-compartment trucks
because of lower fuel costs. "With no
curbside sorting and longer and more
efficient routes for trucks, this allows
the hauler to introduce some level of
automation and lower labor costs."
• And the MRF operator needs less
tipping floor space with a single
stream, says Roche, and with good
sorting equipment, the quality of
grades produced is not compromised.
STAVING OFF THE PROBLEMS
Critics of single-stream processing can point to several potential problem areas, but Roche says early indications are that these potential issues have been addressed upfront.
"In a rural area, what to do with glass can be a problem, with cullet markets few and far between," acknowledges Roche. The county has side-stepped the cullet markets by finding a home for glass recovered at the MRF in civil engineering applications. The Broome County Solid Waste Division uses the glass as aggregate in civil engineering applications, saving the county additional processing and shipping fees.
Higher residue rates have also not been a problem. "I had heard horror stories of high residue rates at programs that went from no recycling program directly to single-stream," says Roche. "But because our residents and haulers have 10 years of two-stream experience behind them, our residue is running at just 4 percent," he remarks.
And the up-front investment and higher processing costs that could occur with new technology have not been burdensome. The way the bid was structured, Waste Management and the County worked to keep capital costs down. Regarding processing costs over the first few months, Roche says, "The processing per ton costs associated with our program actually went down. Everyone thinks of single-stream as more capital intensive; we found that wasn’t the case anymore. The gap has narrowed considerably, so in some cases it’s more efficient to sort and process this way."
Though only at the start of a 10-year contract, Roche sounds confident that the single-stream arrangement is a winner in Binghamton. "What we’ve found is that single-stream does work in a community our size, and it worked without the county making a big investment."
SERVING SMALL TOWN AMERICA
Canada and the U.S. have been valued trading partners with each other going back to the Colonial era. The free trade relationship has helped two Canadian MRF operators keep their workers and facilities on the job.
Haycore Canada Inc., Russell, Ontario, www.haycore.com, is a company with a background in agricultural products and recycling and employees who are familiar with American raw materials markets in New York and New England.
According to Haycore sales and operations manager Bill Renkema, the company’s partnership with two single-stream MRFs in Quebec provided a natural opportunity for Haycore to market processing capacity at the MRFs to American municipalities in counties within reasonable hauling distance of the facilities.
Renkema, who had previously been employed in the solid waste and recycling sector, says the MRFs are independent—one owned by a non-profit entity and the other by a smaller hauling company—and seeking additional materials.
The marketing partnership has existed for two years. "We got a few weird looks from haulers and town officials at first when we presented our proposals," says Renkema. "But after a couple of towns tried it and word started to get around, now we’re pretty well known in the region."
He says the single-stream MRFs offer a service that is attractive for a number of reasons. "We don’t cherry-pick materials—we try to move all materials, so they can add additional materials to their programs."
The company has targeted towns and haulers fitting a particular profile, he notes. "Most of our customer base consists of municipalities with 50,000 people or less; larger cities can make it pay for itself," says Renkema.
Single-stream collection, with its wider basket of materials and ability to compact what is collected, isan easy sell, says Renkema. "We found that with single-stream curbside collection, the cost is fairly equal to garbage collection," he notes. "Then basic economies of scale demonstrate that anyone doing less than 5,000 tons per year is much better off out-sourcing their sorting and baling."
The Canadian MRFs accept all plastic containers, gable-top milk and juice packaging, plastic tubs and lids used in dairy product packaging and almost every type of paper. "Using us, they don’t have to save it and hold it just to make one bale
Get curated news on YOUR industry.
Enter your email to receive our newsletters.

Explore the January 2003 Issue
Check out more from this issue and find your next story to read.
Latest from Recycling Today
- LME reports active Q2
- Liberty Steel assets facing financing deadlines
- Sims is part of Australian recycling loop
- Tariffs target steel exporters Brazil, Canada and South Korea
- Buy Scrap Software to showcase its software at Scrap Expo in September
- LG details recycling activities
- Algoma EAF is up and running
- Toyota-Tsusho completes acquisition of Radius Recycling