IHS Markit JOC: Railroads continue lose price advantage over trucking

U.S. railroads experienced further deterioration of their price advantage for domestic intermodal shipping compared with trucking in the second quarter of 2019, according to a new index by global business information provider IHS Markit. This latest contraction continues a trend that began in the first quarter of 2018. 

The dwindling pricing advantage means shippers have less of a financial incentive to transport cargo “intermodal”—that is via rail, where it is loaded and offloaded by trucks—rather than just using trucking for the entire length of the trip.

The new U.S. Domestic Intermodal Savings Index produced by IHS Markit’s JOC shows that U.S. domestic intermodal shippers do not save as much by converting loads from the highway to the rails as in recent years. Trucking services have been more competitive on lanes less than 2,000 miles, the index shows.

The release of the quarterly index comes as U.S. railroads face slowing freight growth and U.S. trucking spare capacity increases, creating a new buying dynamic for U.S. shippers moving goods via 53-foot containers and trailers, IHS says.

The index is produced by JOC, part of the Maritime & Trade business at IHS Markit. The index is available to JOC.com and The Journal of Commerce magazine subscribers. 

“The new data from the U.S. Domestic Intermodal Savings Index illustrates how shippers and brokers are becoming increasingly sensitive to whether intermodal or trucking is best for the various lanes they manage,” says Ari Ashe, associate editor, JOC, and author of the report. “With C-Suite pressures to keep transportation costs down, shippers are looking to make the most informed decisions about modal choices to wisely spend down.”

The new index uses a base of 100. Values above that mark mean that intermodal spot rates are cheaper. When the index is below 100, that signifies that truckload spot rates are cheaper, IHS says.

Through the first half of 2019, the index is 106.7. Spot intermodal rates have gradually declined since 2015. The index even dropped below 100 on a national basis between August 2018 and October 2018 as intermodal spot market rates shot up higher than trucks in major markets across the country. Although the index has recovered since October, intermodal savings were still lower in the first two quarters compared with one year ago, according to the index.

The new U.S. Domestic Intermodal Savings Index uses a proprietary JOC data set of intermodal and truckload rates through partnerships with various third-party logistics companies and shippers. The truckload information consists of the average of actual invoiced prices issued to shippers in the prior month rather than the rates paid to drivers.

The index evaluates 45 high-volume lanes in which intermodal and full truckload compete for shippers’ business. An additional 60 secondary lanes with both modal options also are tracked to develop a standard index value to facilitate conversations between shippers and their transportation partners about the best solutions for them.

The JOC is the historic Journal of Commerce shipping newspaper that is now a focused business intelligence unit within IHS Markit, concentrating on international containerized transportation and logistics, freight markets, technology and strategy.